By Millie Brecheisen · Updated 17 November 2026.
ACL reconstruction usually replaces the injured ligament with a graft rather than simply stitching it back together. Graft choice also affects the donor site and the strength deficits that rehabilitation needs to address. In Basel, a useful starting point is the operation report: which tissue was used, and were the meniscus, cartilage or other structures treated as well?
Three common autografts, with different trade-offs
An autograft uses your own tissue. All three options below remain established choices. The review of randomised trials by White and colleagues does not identify one universal winner. Average study results cannot choose on their own for someone who kneels at work, sprints or plays a pivoting sport.
| Graft | Potential advantages | Rehabilitation considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Bone–patellar tendon–bone, BPTB | Extensive clinical experience and bone-to-bone incorporation at the graft ends. | Anterior knee or kneeling pain can occur at the donor site; rebuild the extensor mechanism’s tolerance progressively. |
| Hamstring tendon, usually semitendinosus with or without gracilis | Avoids harvesting the patellar tendon, with a different donor-site symptom profile. | Assess and rebuild knee-flexor strength, including in greater knee flexion. |
| Quadriceps tendon, with or without a bone block | Another established option, with lower donor-site morbidity than BPTB in some comparisons. | Quadriceps activation and knee-extension strength need particular attention. |
A 2026 review of randomised trials describes graft-specific patterns of flexor and extensor recovery. These patterns support targeted testing; they do not establish one graft as the best choice for every athlete.
What about donor tissue and additional procedures?
An allograft uses donor tissue. Its suitability depends on age, activity, graft processing and the surgical situation. Evidence from selected adult groups cannot automatically be transferred to a young pivoting athlete. Discuss the reasons for the proposed choice with the surgeon. 2025 autograft–allograft review.
Single- or double-bundle reconstruction, selected repair procedures and a modified Lemaire lateral tenodesis describe other aspects of surgery. Lemaire is an additional lateral stabilisation, not the graft replacing the ACL inside the joint. The exact combination matters more than a short label.
What changes in physiotherapy?
After hamstring harvest, knee-flexor recovery receives particular attention. After quadriceps or patellar tendon harvest, the extensor mechanism and anterior symptoms need close monitoring. This does not mean neglecting the other muscles. The 2023 Aspetar guideline places exercise at the centre of ACL rehabilitation.
- Early rehabilitation addresses permitted extension, swelling, gait and quadriceps activation.
- The next stage progresses resistance, movement range and single-leg tasks according to healing and donor-site tolerance.
- Later work restores running, jumping, braking, direction changes and exposure to actual training demands.
A meniscus repair or cartilage procedure may impose additional weightbearing or flexion restrictions. Graft choice alone therefore cannot define the full programme. Open- and closed-chain exercises are selected and dosed for the stage and clinical presentation; blanket bans or unrestricted use for everyone are too simplistic.
Questions worth discussing before surgery
Ask why this graft suits your goals, which associated injuries will be treated and which restrictions will be passed to your physiotherapist. Explain your occupation, sports and history of anterior knee pain. A sports physiotherapy assessment in Basel can document baseline capacity and practical rehabilitation goals.
The 2024 review of symptoms after patellar tendon harvest shows that reported pain rates vary widely. Such ranges are not an individual forecast. They help frame a discussion about possible donor-site symptoms and how these will be managed.
Frequently asked questions
Does one graft let me return to sport sooner?
No graft name removes the need for tissue healing and functional progression. See the guide to running and return to sport after ACL reconstruction.
Can all three grafts be rehabilitated successfully?
Yes. The important steps are understanding the operation, measuring the relevant deficits and adapting loading, rather than giving every patient the same exercises at the same dose.
Related reading
- Knee injuries and pain in Basel
- Modified Lemaire procedure: why add it to ACL reconstruction?
- Supporting knee rehabilitation: Compex, BFR, compression, cycling and strength
- Knee instability and visual dependence: proprioception, balance and rehabilitation
Knee rehabilitation matched to your goals in Basel
At Physio-Sport Brecheisen, Holbeinstrasse 75, 4051 Basel, assessment brings together symptoms, capacity and activity goals. Bring existing medical reports and postoperative instructions.
Book an appointment · Directions to the practice
Scientific sources and verified information
- White et al. Quadriceps, hamstring and patella tendon autografts: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. Online 2025; issue 2026.
- Hamstring autografts favour knee extension strength recovery while quadriceps autografts optimise flexion strength recovery. Systematic review of RCTs, 2026.
- Peebles et al. Anterior knee pain and kneeling pain after BPTB autograft. Systematic review of level I studies, 2024.
- The results of ACL reconstruction with allograft versus autograft: systematic review and meta-analysis, 2025.
- Kotsifaki et al. Aspetar clinical practice guideline on rehabilitation after ACL reconstruction. BJSM, 2023.


Leave a Reply